Guest perspective: In this article, Loren J. Sanders, VP of Learning and Strategy Consulting at WeLearn, explores why our judgments about our own capabilities aren’t always reliable—and how better evidence can help us make more accurate assessments.
“This would be an inconvenient time for everyone to discover I am not qualified to give a keynote about Impostor Syndrome.”
I recently opened a keynote exactly this way. People laughed. I laughed too.
I was invited to speak, I prepared and knew what I wanted to say. Presumably the people putting me on stage had given the decision at least a little thought. Yet there I was joking about the possibility that we had all made a terrible mistake.
The joke worked because people recognized it. It also raised a question worth taking seriously.
If I had stumbled over something, would that have meant I wasn’t qualified to be there? If the audience loved the presentation would that have established that I was?
Neither would have settled the question on its own.
I’ve spent much of my career helping organizations evaluate capability and performance. You likely have too. We establish standards, gather information and assess results. We still get things wrong.
When we turn that evaluative attention toward ourselves, how much of that discipline do we retain?
When someone dismisses their qualifications or explains away praise, it is tempting to reassure them. We want to recognize what we see.
What if they are right?
What if they are right to question the feedback?
When someone else is being unnecessarily hard on themselves we recognize the problem. It’s tempting to reassure them. Sometimes they explain praise away or dismiss their qualifications. When they do it’s tempting to reassure them.
But what if they’re right to question the feedback?
Praise can be generous without being precise. “You were great” might mean the work met a demanding standard. It might also mean someone appreciated the effort, enjoyed the experience or just wanted to be encouraging.
Those are different kinds of feedback. Before treating praise as evidence of capability, I want to know what the person observed and what they were evaluating.
Now consider someone who makes poor decisions, dismisses difficult feedback or treats one successful outcome as proof of mastery. We are generally less sympathetic to those conclusions. Yet I want to ask the same question in both situations: how well does the available evidence support what this person believes about their capability?
Research gives us a reason to take that question seriously.
In a 2004 review psychologists David Dunning, Chip Heath and Jerry Suls examined the limitations of self-assessment across education, health and the workplace. They documented discrepancies between people’s perceptions of their abilities and measures of their performance or evaluations by others including tendencies toward overestimation and overconfidence.
Research on confirmation bias describes how we can seek or interpret information in ways that favor what we already believe. Research on motivated reasoning examines how what we want to conclude can influence the reasoning we use to get there. Having evidence available does not necessarily mean we are weighing it.
For me the practical question is how to examine a conclusion without turning it into another opportunity to defend it.
Imagine a leader who handles a difficult conversation poorly. Before deciding what it says about their leadership I would want to know what went wrong. Did they avoid the issue, fail to listen, leave expectations unclear? Was this a recurring problem or an unusual situation they weren’t prepared to handle.
Those questions make the conclusion more specific and make it possible to identify what needs to change.
I would want the same discipline if the conversation went well. What did the leader do that helped? What did the outcome demonstrate? What remains untested?
Rather than beginning with “Am I a good leader?” I would start with:
- What specifically am I evaluating?
- What standard am I using?
- What evidence comes from direct observation and what comes from interpretation or encouragement?
- What pattern appears across situations?
- What evidence would give me a reason to revise my conclusions?
These are questions I can use to challenge a flattering assessment, as well as a harsh one.
The consequences matter.
A conclusion about capability can influence whether we pursue an opportunity, accept a responsibility, ask for help or invest in development.
“I’m not leadership material” may close a door before we examine what the role requires. “I am naturally good at this may leave important skill gaps unexamined.
Think about an explanation you have carried about yourself for years. Perhaps someone else supplied it. Maybe you built it around a success, failure or opportunity you never expected to receive. It may have seemed reasonable at the time. What would support it today? What would challenge it?
I wrote Who Let Me In Here? Why Capable People Misjudge Themselves—and How Better Evidence Changes Everything because I was interested in how people’s conclusions influence their decisions, and what happens when they examine evidence more carefully.
I was qualified to deliver that keynote. I had evidence to support that conclusion. I could also have delivered it badly.
Both things can be true.
A poor performance would deserve examination just as much as a successful one.
Neither would relieve me of the responsibility to be specific about what it showed and what it didn’t.
Who let me in here?
In the new book Who Let Me In Here?, Loren takes a closer look at how we evaluate our own capabilities and why those judgments aren’t always reliable.
Grab the book today and learn how evidence-based self-assessment can help us make more informed decisions about our abilities and development.
This article was contributed by Loren J. Sanders as part of WeLearn’s ongoing guest contributor series, featuring perspectives on learning, workforce development, and the future of work.